Big John McCarthy Slams Miragliotta Stand-Up at UFC Vegas 123

Big John McCarthy Slams Miragliotta Stand-Up at UFC Vegas 123
Referee Dan Miragliotta stands between Renato Moicano and Tom Nolan before the UFC Vegas 123 main event. Photo: MMA Fighting

LAS VEGAS — Veteran referee John McCarthy says Dan Miragliotta got it wrong with his controversial second-round stand-up in the UFC Vegas 123 main event between Renato Moicano and Tom Nolan on Saturday night. After Moicano dominated the opening round with back control and a body triangle and secured the same position in round two, Miragliotta ordered the fighters to stand, allowing Nolan to seize momentum before sealing a third-round TKO victory.

Speaking on the Weighing In podcast on Monday, McCarthy criticised the decision in blunt terms. “What’s the purpose of MMA? The purpose of MMA is to showcase that your skillset is better than your opponent’s,” McCarthy said. “But I’ve never taken someone out of back control, because when it gets to back control, how do I tell you to improve? You’ve gotten to the very best position that you can get to in MMA.”

McCarthy, who described Miragliotta as a great guy trying to do what he believes is right, rejected suggestions the call was driven by crowd noise. He argued Miragliotta believed Moicano had been given enough time to finish after almost a full round of back control. “That’s not your responsibility. That’s not your job. Your job is to be fair, and the true factor in this is, you’re being completely unfair to one fighter, because he is doing things,” McCarthy said, noting Moicano threw 20-25 strikes in the final minute before the stand-up while working toward a finish.

McCarthy added that a stand-up is only justified when the fighter in control is genuinely stalling, and said back control should almost never be interrupted. “You cannot make a bad fight good, but you can definitely make a good fight bad,” McCarthy said. “I’m not saying this ended up being a bad fight; it was exciting with what Nolan did, but he was given the opportunity to be in positions that he never should have been in.”

McCarthy called Miragliotta a fantastic person and a fantastic official who has made a mistake all officials can learn from. The defeat left Moicano furious, with the Brazilian having already voiced his anger at Miragliotta’s officiating after the loss to Nolan.